Gem Grill & Pizzeria Menu (2025 Update)
Welcome to Gem Grill & Pizzeria, a hidden treasure located in Cape May Court House, NJ. This charming eatery brings a delightful blend of comfort food and hearty meals that cater to everyone. Whether you're in the mood for a classic cheesesteak, a vibrant quesadilla, or their signature pizzas, all crafted with high-quality ingredients, you're in for a treat.
The menu features enticing options, including cold deli sandwiches like home-cooked turkey and imported ham, alongside a dedicated kids' corner that promises satisfaction for younger diners. Reviews highlight the exceptional flavor and friendly service, with many customers returning for the BBQ and buffalo chicken quesadillas and the must-try white pizza topped with mushrooms, chicken, and ricotta.
With a focus on quality and community, Gem Grill & Pizzeria is truly a local gem worth visiting.
STROMBOLI
PLAIN
Mozzarella Cheese & Sauce
GEM STEAK
Pepperoni, Bacon, Fried Onion, Mushrooms, Garlic & Provolone
CHEESE STEAK
Steak & Fried Onions
ITALIAN
Genoa, Cooked Salami, Cappacola & Provolone
CHICKEN PARMESAN
BUFFALO CHICKEN
Chicken, Hot Sauce, Bleu Cheese on the side
VEGGIE
Broccoli, Mushrooms, Spinach, Green Peppers, Tomatoes & Onions
MEAT LOVERS
Pepperoni, Sausage & Meatballs
BACON CHEESEBURGER
Ground Beef, Bacon, Cheez Wiz, Mozzarella & Sauce
CHEESE
HOMEMADE PEPPERONI
PIZZA BY THE SLICE
9" PERSONAL PIZZA ANY COMBO
Up to 3 toppings free
HAND TOSSED PIZZA
SPECIALTY PIZZAS
GEM PIZZA
Pepperoni, Sausage, Mushrooms, Green Peppers & Onions
MEAT LOVERS
Pepperoni, Sausage, Meatball, & Bacon
THREE CHEESE
Mozzarella, Provolone, Cheddar Cheese
PB & J PIZZA
Pepperoni, Bacon, & Jalapenos
VEGGIE PIZZA
Garlic, Broccoli, Spinach, Sweet Peppers & Plum Tomatoes
MY WAY PIZZA
Create your own with combo of any three toppings
BUFFALO CHICKEN
Spicy Buffalo Sauce, Diced Chicken & Bleu Cheese on side
BACON CHEESE BURGER PIZZA
Ground Beef, Crispy Bacon & extra Cheddar Cheese
BBQ BACON CHICKEN
BBQ Sauce, Chicken, Bacon, Cheddar & Mozzarella Cheese
CAROLINA PULLED PORK PIZZA
Served with side of Coleslaw
HAWAIIAN PIZZA
Pineapples and Virginia Baked Ham
MARGARITA PIZZA
Fresh Mozzarella & basil
MIKE'S HOT HONEY & PEPPERONI
FRESH GARLIC, OLIVE OIL, MOZZARELLA & RICOTTA CHEESE
EPIC GREEK
Spinach, Feta Cheese, Kalamata Olives & Red Onions
B&T PIZZA
Bacon & Plum Tomatoes
HAWAIIAN
Pineapples & Virginia Baked Ham
VEGGIE PIZZA
Broccoli, Spinach & Tomato
GEM PIZZA
Grilled Chicken, Spinach & Mushrooms
TOMATO BASIL
Diced Plum Tomatoes & Fresh Basil
Prosciutto, Roasted Peppers & Spinach
WHITE PIZZA
CHICAGO DEEP DISH PIZZA
REGULAR
Layers of Mozzarella Cheese, Rich Tomato Sauce, & a Crispy Deep Crust
VEGGIE DEEP DISH
Green Peppers, Red Onions, Sweet Peppers, Mushrooms & Fresh Spinach
GEM SPECIAL DEEP DISH
Pepperoni, Sausage, & Meatballs with layers of Mozzarella Cheese, Rich Tomato Sauce, & a Crispy Deep Crust
ULTIMATE DEEP DISH
Prosciutto, Roasted Peppers, Ricotta Cheese, Fresh Basil, with layers of Mozzarella Cheese, Rich Tomato Sauce, & Crispy Deep Crust
RED & WHITE DEEP DISH
Ricotta Cheese, Pepperoni, & Garlic, layers of Mozzarella Cheese, Rich Tomato Sauce, & a Crispy Deep Crust
PLAIN
Mozzarella & Ricotta served with homemade sauce on the side
MEAT LOVERS
Pepperoni, Sausage & Meatballs
GRILLED STEAK CALZONE
With Ricotta & Mozzarella
GEM STEAK
Pepperoni, Bacon, Fried Onion, Mushrooms, Garlic & Provolone
SAUTEED SHRIMP IN SCAMPI SAUCE
EPIC GREEK
Spinach, Feta Cheese, Kalamata Olives & Red Onion
ITALIAN
Genoa, Cooked Salami, Cappacola & Provolone
VEGGIE
Broccoli, Mushrooms, Spinach, Green Peppers, Tomatoes & Onions
ITALIAN PROSCIUTTO, ROASTED RED PEPPERS & FRESH SPINACH
CALZONE
BREAKFAST
PROSCIUTTO, ROASTED PEPPERS
With aged Provolone, & Scrambled Eggs
BANANA PANCAKES
2 Pancakes, with fresh Banana Chunks served on a Soft Bun
CHOCOLATE CHIP BANANA PANCAKES
2 Pancakes, with fresh Banana Chunks & Chocolate Chips
GEM BREAKFAST BURRITO
3 Scrambled Eggs, Virginia Ham, Fried Onions, Salsa, & Pepper Jack Cheese
PANCAKE PLATTER
3 PANCAKES, CHOICE OF MEAT AND HOME FRIES
BREAKFAST SANDWICH
(2 Eggs any style on Kaiser, Bread, or Wrap 0.30)
FRENCH TOAST BAGEL SANDWICH
Choice of Meat & Cheese I Served with Maple Syrup for dipping
THREE EGG OMELET WITH CHOICE OF TOAST
(ANY COMBO MADE TO ORDER)
CHEESE OMELET
BREAKFAST PLATTER
2 Eggs any style, Home Fries, Toast & choice of: Bacon, Sausage, Pork Roll, Ham, or Scrapple
MUSHROOM, SPINACH, AND CHEESE OMELET
HAM AND CHEESE OMELET
FRENCH TOAST
3 pieces of Texas Toast with Butter and Syrup
WESTERN
Green Peppers, Onions & Ham
GREEK OMELET WITH FETA & SPINACH
FRENCH TOAST PLATTER
3 pieces of Texas Toast, choice of Meat and Home Fries
TOASTED BAGEL WITH CREAM
CHEESE AND BACON
SHORT STACK
2 Pancakes, with Butter and Syrup
ULTIMATE BF SANDWICH
(3) Scrambled Eggs, Choice of Meat, Pepper Jack Ch, Avocado, Hot Sauce and Hash Brown served on a Toasted Garlic Bread Roll
PANCAKES
3 Pancakes, with Butter and Syrup
CHOCOLATE CHIP PANCAKES
(KIDS LOVE ME!) 2 Pancakes, with Chocolate Chips
GEM HOME FRIES
TOASTED BAGEL WITH BUTTER
TOASTED BAGEL WITH CREAM CHEESE
HASH BROWNS
(new Wedge Size!)
HOME FRIES
(Fresh Seasoned Red Skin Potatoes)
MEAT
(Pork Roll, Sausage, Ham, Bacon, or Scrapple)
BREAKFAST SIDE ORDERS
KIDS CORNER
CHICKEN NUGGETS (6)
(White Meat)
MAC & CHEESE
GRILLED CHEESE
CHEESEBURGER SLIDERS (2)
CHICKEN TENDERS (4)
CHEESE QUESADILLA
KIDS SPAGHETTI & MARINARA
CHEESE RAVIOLIS (4)
HOMEMADE N.Y. CHEESE CAKE
Slice 49.99 Whole
CARROT CAKE
Slice
HANDMADE CANNOLI (6)
DESSERTS
APPETIZERS & SIDE ORDERS
BOARD WALK FRENCH FRIES
JALAPENO POPPERS (CHEDDAR) (4)
CHEESE FRIES with Cheese Wiz
CHICKEN TENDERS (4)
BBQ, Honey Mustard, Sweet & Sour
BACON & RANCH MOZZ. CHEESE FRIES
GRAVY FRIES
GARLIC BREAD STICKS (5)
With Marinara & Garlic Butter
CURLY SEASONED FRIES
BUSHES BAKED BEANS
PIZZA FRIES
STOUFFER'S MACARONI & CHEESE
ONION RINGS
CHEESE ONION RINGS
MOZZARELLA STICKS (4)
BROCCOLI BITES (10)
DEEP FRIED MUSHROOMS (10)
PRETZEL STICKS & BEIR CHEESE DIP SAUCE
OLD BAY CHEESE FRY
CURLY CHEESE FRIES
CHEESE STEAK EGG ROLLS WITH FRIED ONIONS
BUFFALO SHRIMP (12) WITH BLEU CHEESE
JACK DANIEL BURGER SLIDER
(3 per order) Black Angus Beef with Jack Daniel Sauce & Cheddar Cheese
BBQ PULLED PORK SLIDERS
(3 per order) With Coleslaw, BBQ Sauce & Provolone
CHICKEN BREAST SLIDER
With Bacon, Sliced Plum Tomato, Ranch Dressing & American Cheese
CRAB CAKE SLIDER
Maryland Crabmeat, Tartar Sauce, Lettuce & Tomato
MAHI MAHI FILET SLIDER
With Plum Tomato, Red Onion, Dill pickle & Basil Honey Mayo
SLIDER SELECTIONS
SALADS
BIG GREEK SALAD
Spinach, Tomato, Red Onions, Kalamata Olives, and Feta Cheese
COBB SALAD
Mixed Greens, Bacon, Tomato, Turkey, Chopped Egg, Cucumber
GARDEN SALAD
Mixed Greens, Tomato, Onion, Cucumbers, Green and Sweet Peppers & Croutons
BUFFALO CHICKEN SALAD
Grilled Buffalo Chicken over Mixed Greens, Tomato & Bleu Cheese Dressing
CHICKEN OR TUNA SALAD
Mixed Greens, Tomato, Onion, Sweet Peppers & Cucumbers
CHICKEN SPINACH TORTELLINI SALAD
Mixed Greens, Tomato, Onion, Sweet Peppers & Cucumbers
CHEF SALAD
Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Sweet Peppers, Cucumbers & Green Peppers
SOUTHWESTERN SALAD
Mixed Greens, Grape Tomatoes, Corn, Black Beans, Cucumbers, Grilled Chicken, Avocados with BBQ Ranch Dressing
ANTIPASTA SALAD
Strips of Genoa, Capacola, Pepperoni, Provolone, Mixed Greens, Tomato, Onion, Sweet Peppers & Black Olives
SPINACH SALAD
Dried Cranberries, Walnuts, Crumbled Bleu Cheese with a side of Balsamic Dressing
CHICKEN CAESAR SALAD
Romaine, Strips of Chicken, Parmesan Cheese, and Croutons.
BURGER
Never Frozen & Cooked to Order!
GEM BURGER
CHEESE BURGER
BACON CHEESE BURGER
PIZZA BURGER
BLACKENED BBQ BACON BURGER
With Smoked Mozzarella & Jalapenos
VEGGIE BURGER
comes with lettuce, tomatoes, onions
BACON BLEU CHEESE BURGER
Crispy Bacon, & Creamy Bleu Cheese
PORKROLL EGG & CHEESE BURGER
Burger topped with grilled porkroll, over easy egg and melted am cheese
BURGERS
CLUBS & MELTS
TURKEY CLUB
ROAST BEEF CLUB
TUNA CLUB
BLT CLUB
CHICKEN SALAD CLUB
TUNA MELT
Tuna, Tomato, choice of Cheese & baked to perfection
SHANESTAR
Chicken Breast, American Cheese, Blue Cheese, Parmesan Cheese, Honey Smoked Bacon and Hot Sauce
CHEESE
Stuffed with melted cheddar jackcheese in a grilled flour tortilla Includes: Salsa, Sour Cream, Jalapenos, Lettuce & Tomato
GRILLED CHICKEN
BBQ CHICKEN
BUFFALO CHICKEN
VEGGIE
Peppers, Onions, Mushrooms & Broccoli
QUESADILLAS
WORLD FAMOUS STEAKS
CHEESE STEAK
PIZZA CHICKEN CHEESE STEAK
Pizza Sauce and Provolone
CHEESE STEAK WITH CHEEZ WHIZ
ALFREDO CHICKEN CHEESE STEAK
Alfredo Sauce, Parm Cheese, & Provolone
GEM STEAK
Fried Onion, Mushrooms, Bacon, & Aged Provolone
JALAPENO CHICKEN CHEESE STEAK
Diced Jalapenos, Cheez Whiz
VEGGIE SUB
Green Peppers, Sweet Peppers, Onions, Mushrooms, Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, & Broccoli
STEAK & EGGS
GARLIC BREAD CHEESE STEAK
SHRIMP SCAMPI CHICKEN CHEESE STEAK
Fresh Shrimp, Homemade Scampi Sauce
G-THING CHEESE STEAK
Buffalo BBQ Chicken Cheese Steak and Creamy Ricotta Cheese
SKY HIGH CHEESE STEAK
Topped with Jalapenos, Cheese Whiz, and Crispy Onion Rings
EXPLODER
Pizza steak with Spicy Sausage Crumbles
GREEK TITAN
Grilled Chicken, Jalapenos, Fried Onions, Lettuce, Tomato, Swiss Cheese & Italian Dressing
SOUTHWESTERN
Grilled Chicken with Peppers, Onions, Topped with Melted Cheddar & Jalapeno Cilantro Pesto
BUFFALO SHRIMP
(12) Jumbo Shrimp, Hot Sauce, Lettuce, Bleu Cheese & Celery
CHICKEN CAESAR
Grilled Chicken, Romaine, Parmesan Cheese, Garlic Croutons with Caesar Dressing
GRILLED VEGGIE
Mushrooms, Sweet & Green Peppers, Fried Onions, Lettuce, Tomato & Provolone
BUFFALO CHICKEN
Grilled Chicken, Spicy Hot Sauce, Bleu Cheese, Lettuce & Celery
ROAST BEEF & PROVOLONE
Homemade Roast Beef, Aged Provolone
BBQ CHICKEN
Grilled Chicken, Hickory Smoked BBQ Sauce with choice of Cheese
MAC
Breaded Eggplant, layered with Mozzarella Cheese, Fresh Basil, Roasted Red Peppers and Drizzled with Balsamic Vinaigrette
MESA WRAP
Blackened Chicken, Corn & Black Bean Salsa, Cilantro & Jalapenos with Cheddar Cheese
FUSSER
Grilled Chicken, Fresh Spinach, Candied Walnuts, Dried Cranberries, Bleu Cheese Crumbles & Balsamic Dressing
CHICKEN RANCH CLUB
Grilled Chicken, Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato & Ranch Dressing
MEAN GENE
Grilled Chicken, Cheez Whiz, Jalapenos, Salsa & Sour Cream
CHICKEN, BACON, AVOCADO
Grilled Chicken, Bacon, Avocado, Tomato & Ranch Dressing
WRAPS
HOT SANDWICHES & SUBS
CHICKEN PARMESAN
CHICKEN BREAST SANDWICH
5oz. All White Meat Make it blackened! Only 0.50!
PETER MELT
Grilled Turkey on Sourdough Grilled Cheese, with Bacon, Tomato, & Russian Dressing
CHICKEN CORDON BLEU
Virginia Baked Ham, Swiss
ROASTED PORK LOIN SANDWICH
Home cooked with Spinach, Roasted Peppers, Sharp Provolone, Toasted Roll
CARIBBEAN MAHI MAHI FILET SANDWICH
Grilled Mahi Red Onions, Tomatoes, Pickles, & Sweet Basil Lime Mayo
MONSTER GRILLED CHEESE
With Grilled Virginia Ham 9.99
HOMEMADE BBQ PULLED PORK
SHANER
Chicken Breast, Sauteed Spinach, Bacon, Red Onions, Provolone Cheese with a Cajun Remoulade Sauce
ITALIAN SAUSAGE PARM SANDWICH
Hot or Sweet Sausage
ITALIAN VEAL CUTLET PARM SANDWICH
SHRIMP PO-BOY
Fried Shrimp on a Garlic Bread Roll with Lettuce & Tomato and Cajun Remoulade Sauce
HOT ROAST BEEF & GRAVY
Served on a long Roll
SLOW MO ROAST
Grilled Roast Beef with Caramelized Onions, Bleu Ch Crumbles, Aged Provolone, Garlic Aioli on a Toasted Long Roll
GRILLED ROAST BEEF & AGED SHARP PROVOLONE
With Roasted Peppers & Chipotle Mayo
CRAB CAKE
Lump Crab Meat on a Toasted Kaiser with Lettuce, Tomato, & Tartar Sauce
MEATBALL PARM SANDWICH
Marinara Sauce & Provolone
HOT LEAN CORNED BEEF SPECIAL
Coleslaw, Russian
RUEBEN
Russian, Sauerkraut, Swiss
CUBAN
Grilled Ham, Turkey, Swiss Pickles, Mustard on Kaiser
FLOUNDER FILET SANDWICH
On Toasted Kaiser with Tartar, Lettuce & Tomato
ITALIAN
Genoa, Cappacola, Cooked Salami, Provolone
TURKEY
HAM
ROAST BEEF
ULTIMATE ITALIAN
Genoa, Cappacola, Sopressata, Proscuitto
PROSCIUTTO & PROVOLONE
TUNA SALAD
AMERICAN
Imported Ham, Bologna & American Cheese
CAJUN CHICKEN SALAD
THREE CHEESE
American, Provolone, Swiss
COLD HOAGIES
COLD DELI SANDWICHES
LIVERWURST
CAJUN CHICKEN SALAD
SOLID WHITE TUNA SALAD
BLT
(7 PIECES OF BACON)
IMPORTED HAM
HOME COOKED TURKEY
HOME COOKED ROAST BEEF
CORNED BEEF SPECIAL
Russian Dressing, Coleslaw on Rye
CHICKEN WINGS
6 Wings Choices of Sauces are as follows: Traditional, Mild Buffalo, Asian Garlic, Thermo, Keith Hot "Super Hot", Mango Habenero, Carolina Tangy BBQ (Extra Bleu Cheese 1.00)
TAIL TENDERS
6 Tails
CHICKEN NUGGETS
6 Pieces
GEM CHICKEN CORNER
GEM PLATTERS
CHEESE BURGER PLATTER
Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Pickles. Cooked to order!
CHEESE STEAK PLATTER
FRIED SHRIMP PLATTER
With Cocktail Sauce
FLOUNDER PLATTER
Two Filets & Tartar Sauce
CRAB CAKE PLATTER
2 bigger lump Crab-meat Cakes, Served with a side of Tartar Sauce
CHICKEN TENDER PLATTER
Honey Mustard, BBQ, or Sweet & Sour Sauce
OPEN FACE TURKEY PLATTER
OPEN FACE ROAST BEEF PLATTER
HOMEMADE BUFFALO TAIL TENDER PLATTER
5 Tails, with choice of Hot Sauce, Bleu Cheese & Celery
PASTA WITH MEATBALLS
Made with Beef, Veal, & Pork or Sausage
STUFFED SHELLS (5)
Jumbo Shells filled with Ricotta and Mozzarella
PASTA WITH BUTTER AND GARLIC
ALFREDO WITH CHICKEN & BROCCOLI
Tender Chicken, Broccoli Florets and rich Alfredo Sauce
MEATBALLS (3)
2 oz. homemade with Beef, Veal & Pork
CHICKEN PARM
1/2 lb. of Italian Chicken Cutlets. Baked with Mozzarella, served over Pasta
VEAL PARM
Breaded Veal Cutlet. Topped with Mozz. Cheese, Marinara Sauce served over Pasta
ITALIAN SAUSAGE
Choice of Hot or Sweet (2-rope pieces)
BAKED ZITI
Marinara Sauce, Mozz. Cheese & Ricotta Cheese
BAKED SAUSAGE ZITI
Hot or Sweet Sausage
BAKED MEATBALL ZITI
Homemade Meatballs
EGGPLANT PARM
Breaded Eggplant topped with Mozzarella, served over Pasta
CHEESE RAVIOLI
Creamy Ricotta Cheese Blend
SHRIMP & BROCCOLI SCAMPI
Jumbo Shrimp & Fresh Spinach, Roasted Peppers in a Garlic Rosa Sauce!
SHRIMP FRA DIABLO
(6) large Shrimp in Spicy Marinara and Mozz. Cheese
PASTA GEM STYLE
Choice of Pasta Chicken Breast, American Cheese, Blue Cheese, Parmesan Cheese, Honey Smoked Bacon and Hot Sauce
TRI-COLOR CHEESE TORTELLINI
With Proscuitto, Peas in a light Cream Sauce